By
Herbie J Pilato
On Saturday night, September 20
th, 1986, the legendary
Lucille Ball partnered with producers
Aaron Spelling and
Douglas S. Cramer, and brought back to the small-screen a sitcom that chronicled the updated adventures of Ball's iconic
Lucy persona.
This time, the actress played grand-mother
Lucille Barker, who resided in Pasadena, California, with her daughter, son-in-law, two grandchildren, and in-law grand-father/hardware-store-business-partner
Curtis McGibbons, played by
Gale Gordon.
As
Lucy fans around the globe very well know, Gordon had appeared with Ball on each of the earlier
Lucy incarnations in one capacity or the other. On
I Love Lucy (CBS, 1951-57), in which Ball co-starred with husband
Desi Arnaz, she had originally cast Gordon as neighbor
Fred Mertz. But the actor was unavailable for the role that ultimately went to
William Frawley (who later appeared on CBS'
My Three Sons with Fred McMurray). Gordon, however, did have the chance to at least guest-star on
Love, and its later expanded edition,
The Lucy Desi Comedy Hour (CBS, 1957-60)
After Ball and Arnaz divorced, and the
Hour was no more, the comedic actress returned to TV with
The Lucy Show, (CBS, 1962-68), and this time Gordon was available on a regular basis, and was cast as the banker
Mr. Mooney to Ball's
Mrs. Carmichael. A few years later, Ball reworked her TV presence once more, and played
Lucy Carter on
Here's Lucy (CBS, 1968-74) with Gordon portraying brother-in-law
Harrison Carter.
Some 12 years after
Here's Lucy left CBS,
Life With Lucy arrived on ABC.
In between those years, Ball guest-starred on variety programs like
The Dean Martin Show, and
The Bob Hope Specials, and made a few of her own specials for CBS, some of which had dramatic elements. She then dramatically exited the
tiffany network for a short affair with NBC.
Yet it was with ABC's
Life With Lucy that the actress returned to her beloved red-headed roots on a weekly basis.
In addition to Gordon's return to her side on
Life (as the staple second banana - a position he embraced and revered), Ball hired long-time
Lucy scribes
Madelyn Pugh Davis and
Bob Carroll, Jr., while second husband Gary Morton (a former stand-up comic) joined Spelling and Cramer as
Life's co-producers.
The time for
Life seemed right. Ball had recently appeared in a highly-rated TV-movie for CBS, titled
Stone Pillow, in which she played a homeless woman. Her performance was heralded by critics and
Lucy fans alike, and everyone deemed it a period for Ball to come back to weekly TV.
Consequently,
Life With Lucy was born.
Unfortunately, it then died a very quick and painful death.
Thirteen episodes were produced, but only seven were aired. The first episode, titled,
One Good Grandparent Deserves Another, cleared the
Top Twenty in the ratings, but the critics were brutal. In subsequent weeks, the audience dwindled.
The overt negative reactions from fans and critics alike devastated Ball, so much so, she later appeared on
The Joan Rivers Show, and wept.
There were attacks from critics and fans about the writing. The show was called archaic and out of step with the times. What's more, Ball was now in her late seventies, and years of smoking and not properly catering to her health (an ironic twist, as her
Lucy Barker character from
Life was defined as health-conscious) had taken its toll.
In event, the
Life complaints had crippled her. Ball was no longer young, and her brand of slapstick comedy had out-worn its welcome, a tad shy of Nick at Nite's retro TV resurgence (which commenced a mere three years later in 1989, with an all-new network dedicated to all old shows).
Life With Lucy was rejected, and the real life
Lucy took it personal. She felt unloved, by fans, critics, and colleagues. She was overcome by the insecurities possessed by many performers, particularly, comedic performers. Her skin was not thick enough; her mind-set could not bear the unyielding attacks, of which she simply was not prepared.
As a result, the once enthusiastically-promoted
Life With Lucy was no more – and in time, so would be the case with Lucille Ball herself. In 1989, at age 77, she died of heart troubles, or a troubled heart...in the form of a ruptured aorta. Ironically, this was same disorder that, in 2003, would kill
John Ritter, who Lucy had adored for years as the star of
Three's Company (and who guest-starred on
Life's second aired-episode,
Lucy Makes A Hit With John Ritter).
However one decides to word it, Lucille Ball had been fired, and that was simply something that the esteemed actress had never experienced. It was a development that ultimately proved too much for her to take. A glowing small screen image that was introduced to the world with
I Love Lucy, and that classic shows iconic big-heart in its logo, had now died of a broken heart (again, however one decides to word it). Ball's adoring personal and public fans were no where in sight. Seemingly, they had deserted her and dwindled away some thirty years after the world fell in
Love with
Lucy.
After Ball's demise, millions of
Lucy fans then came out of the woodwork and mourned. Lines reaching around the block surrounded the hospital in which she was attended during her final days.
Had
Life With Lucy been given a fair shake, the story may have ended differently.
Life With Lucy had its issues, but any new television show needs time find its pace.
Life was no different. Its development required patience – from all of those involved with its production, and from Lucy's fans. Had it been granted at least one season, or maybe two,
Life would have found its rhythm. The episodes were sweet, and in many instances superior to a few segments that were presented on
Here's Lucy.
The
Life character of
Lucy Barker had infinite more texture than both
Lucy Carter on
Here's Lucy and
Lucy Carmichael on
The Lucy Show. Lucy's
Carter had legitimate emotions and interactions that were displayed realistically for a TV character in her age bracket (particularly in the era of
The Golden Girls, which aired Saturday nights on NBC, one hour after
Life).
Lucy Barker interacted with her fellow TV characters in charming ways. Yes, the comedy was somewhat broad, and maybe a little out of date (as well as slightly jarring for viewers who were somewhat aghast to see the aged actress performing so physically for her age). But the show had promise, and it deserved an opportunity to shine.
Upon viewing each subsequent episode, it became clear the show was improving, and that Lucille was having a ball. She allowed her co-stars their comedic on-screen moments, and seemed to delight in their performances in a combined reaction as both
Lucy Barker and Lucille Ball.
With a career that spanned decades, Lucille Ball, the actress, could deliver a line of dialogue and dance with the best of them (and she did). Although she could only slightly carry a tune (by her own admission), the spectacular thespian was able to pull off any vocal performance with charismatic appeal. As one of the most outstanding entertainers in the history of the industry, she contributed a great deal to so many in countless ways for ages.
In short, Lucille Ball in her later years deserved more than the heartless attacks and abandonment that she received by way of
Life With Lucy.
Herbie J Pilato is a producer/director/writer, and author of a number of media tie-in books (including Bewitched Forever and The Kung Fu Book Of Caine, Life Story – The Book of Life Goes On: TV's First And best Family Show of Challenge, The Bionic Book, and NBC & ME: My Life As A Page In A Book. He's worked for A&E, TLC, Syfy, and Bravo's hit five-part TV series, The 100 Greatest TV Characters. Herbie J is also the Founder and Executive Director of The Classic TV Preservation Society, a nonprofit organization that helps to close the gap between popular culture and education. For more information, please see www.ClassicTVPS.blogspot.com. To contact Herbie J, or to order any of his books, email: ClassicTVPS@gmail.com.
